Josh (shyguyjosh) wrote in literarycircles,

  • Music:

fight club

I think it kinda diminishes the effect of the book having watched the movie, but it was a still bloody good read! the narrator is just this great character and voice and the book is just overflowing with all these great/humourous/shocking/quotable lines. unfortunately, the movie just about used all of them...and rightly so. what was with the hospital ending though? i preferred the movie's ending. it just seemed like it's last quarter just lost whatever the rest of the book had and became trite and lame and repetitive. and i didn't think marla was well characterised in the book. in the movie she was this convincing washed up sarcastic character, but in the book she was just a little too obsessed with tyler and the way she forgave him immediately for shooting that guy...i really didn't buy that. i don't know maybe just the awesomeness of the movie finishing with the pixies is colouring my opinion. when i was thinking about it before, i really had a lot more positives to say. it was a nice change of pace from all the fantasy books i've been reading, they're always a slog, but this i raced through! i think it's because the sentences are so short. in conclusion, i liked it a lot, hated the ending, biased by the movie.
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.